Dutton, W.H. (1999), Society on the Line: Information Politics in the Digital Age (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Society on the Line: Information Politics in the Digital Age

by William H. Dutton

with the assistance of Malcolm Peltu and essays by Margaret Bruce, Martin Cave, James Cornford, Rod Coombs, Nicholas Garnham, Andrew Gillespie, John Goddard, Leslie Haddon, David Knights, Dale Littler, Donald MacKenzie, Robin Mansell, lan Miles, Vincent Porter, Charles Raab, Ranald Richardson, Roger Silverstone, David Stout, John Taylor, Juliet Webster, Steve Woolgar, Robin Williams, and Hugh Wilmott.

For information on how to order Society on the Line, click here

Overview

This book presents a new way of thinking about the social and economic implications of the revolution in information and communication technologies (ICTs). It offers a critical perspective on information politics in the digital age - the way social and technical choices about ICTs influence access to information, people, services, and technologies themselves. I have called this process 'the shaping of tele-access' and this book shows how this concept challenges prevailing theoretical perspectives on the information and communication revolution. It also proposes a framework for policy and practice, for the shaping of tele-access is directly connected to choices in everyday life, to strategies in the workplace, to the application of ICTs in government, education, and the household, and to issues of public policy.

My focus on the social shaping of tele-access evolved from an effort to synthesize a decade of research undertaken by the UK's Programme on Information and Communication Technologies (PICT). Supported by grants from the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) of Britain, PICT was one of the most ambitious social research initiatives in Europe to be focused on the role of ICTs in social and economic development.

PICT involved numerous social scientists from different disciplines geographers, management scientists, political-economists, and sociologists at six university research centres across the UK. They published dozens of books and hundreds of articles based on their PICT research, contributing many new concepts and themes to the literature, and influencing contemporary understanding of the social shaping, and impacts of ICTs.

The wide range and significance of PICT research led to a programme-wide synthesis during the final years of the programme. I joined PICT as its national director at the launch of this final synthesis phase. One of my major responsibilities was to determine if the programme as a whole added up to more than the sum of its parts. This goal led me on a search for an integrative concept or theme that could encapsulate the central contributions across the full range of PICT research.

I needed an all-embracing concept that would achieve three related objectives. First, it was important to synthesize and extend all the most important themes of PICT research, and not focus on one particular stream of work. Secondly, I wanted a concept that applied well to the full range of ICTs, from business networks to the mass media, as well as the many different arenas of ICT adoption and use. These arenas, most of which were covered by the PICT programme, include such different social contexts as the business and management use of ICTs, and the ways ICTs are used in government, education, and the household. Finally, it was critical that this concept should signify the opportunities as well as the dangers - the benefits as well as the risks - of the development and diffusion of ICTs.

I found this all-embracing theme in the shaping of tele-access. Having worked with this idea, I believe it can help integrate the findings of research on ICTs across the social sciences generally. Many social and economic issues ranging from issues of information inequality, privacy, and censorship, to the role of the Internet, and information superhighways in economic development can be better understood if viewed as products of a process that is quite literally reshaping social and economic access in this digital age of new ICTs.

The main narrative of this book is my personal synthesis of research and focuses one the process of shaping tele-access. The meaning of 'tele-access' is explained in Chapter 1. The remaining chapters elaborate this perspective on the politics of information, distinguish it from other concepts guiding research on ICTs, and discuss the factors shaping tele-access and its significance in a variety of arenas, including the production of ICTs, their use in business and industry, in households and communities, and in public policy.

You will find within this main narrative a set of original essays contributed by other PICT researchers. Their analytical approach to challenging commonly accepted assumptions about the information society generated many creative ideas, and I have included these essays to expand on the contributions of my colleagues, and also to show how my understanding of the technical and social processes shaping tele-access is built on their work.

This book is one of two companion volumes. The first, entitled Information and Communication Technologies - Visions and Realities (Dutton 1996), pools the key themes of major research projects, lectures, and forums of the PICT programme. This book also draws extensively on PICT as well as my own research, but goes beyond the first volume to offer a new perspective on social and policy choices of the coming digital age.

Contents

List of Essays xiv
List of Contributors xvi
List of Figures xxi
List of Tables xxii
List of Boxes xxiii
List of Abbreviations and Acronymsxxvii
Part I. A New Perspective on the Information Revolution
1 Introduction: Tele-Access -- The Outcome of an Ecology of Games 3
2 Information Politics, Technology, and Society 29
Part II. Social Dimensions of the Technical: Social, Cultural, and Political Processes Shaping Tele-Access 76
3 Technologies Shaping Tele-Access: A Force for Social Change77
4 The Social Shaping of Tele-Access: Inventing our Futures 127
Part III. Tele-Access in Business, Management, and Work 179
5 The Reach and Boundaries of Business and Management: Virtual Organizations 180
6 Redesigning the Workplace: Challenging Geographical and Cultural Constraints on Access 227
Part IV. Public Access in Politics, Governance, and Education 277
7 Digital Democracy: Electronic Access to Politics and Services278
8 Knowledge Gatekeepers: ICTs in Teaching and Research 326
Part V. The Virtual City: Shaping Access in Everyday Life 363
9 The Intelligent Household: For Richer or Poorer 364
10 Wiring the Global Village: Shaping Access to Audiences 414
Part VI. Industrial Strategies and Public Policies 456
11 Regulating Access: Broadening the Policy Debate 460
12 The Politics of Tele-Access: Social Relations in a Network Society 519
Appendix The Programme on Information and Communication Technologies (PICT) 550
Glossary 559
Bibliography 569
Index 649
List of Essays
2.1. Technological Determinism DONALD MACKENZIE 41
2.2. The Social Shaping of Technology ROBIN WILLIAMS 47
2.3. The Certainty Trough DONALD MACKENZIE 61
3.1. Barriers to Convergence NICHOLAS GARNHAM 88
3.2. ICT Innovations in Services IAN MILES 96
3.3. Information Politics: The Study of Communicative Power NICHOLAS GARNHAM 108
4.1. Interpreting Conceptions of the Networked Organization' DAVID KNIGHTS AND HUGH WILLMOTT 138
4.2. Home Informatics: New Consumer Technologies IAN MILES 153
5.1. Information Systems and Management Control ROD COOMBS193
5.2. Collaborative Product Development MARGARET BRUCE AND DALE LITTLER 219
6.1. Home-Based Telework LESLIE HADDON AND ROGER SILVERSTONE243
6.2. The Impact of Remote Work on Employment Location and Work Processes RANALD RICHARDSON AND ANDREW GILLESPIE 254
6.3. Women's Access to ICT-related Work JULIET WEBSTER 265
7.1. The Information Polity JOHN TAYLOR 282
7.2. Protecting Privacy CHARLES RAAB 316
9.1. Domesticating ICTs ROGER SILVERSTONE371
9.2. Gender and Domestication of the Home Computer LESLIE HADDON 379
9.3. The Geography of Network Access JAMES CORNFORD AND ANDREW GILLESPIE 402
10.1. The Bias of Information Infrastructures ROBIN MANSELL438
11.1. The Interlocking Pieces of the Information Economy ROBIN MANSELL471
11.2. Competition in Telecommunications MARTIN CAVE 486
11.3. Intellectual Property Rights VINCENT PORTER 505
12.1. ICTs and Technology Foresight DAVID STOUT 521
12.2. Analytic Scepticism STEVE WOOLGAR 532

Return home